There are three actual stories in this book but they all have one common thread. That common subject lies in a building, which has had many purposes over the years, if only the walls of that building could talk.
I liked the idea of how this huge building served many purposes over the years. The history that this building contained and how it served others was fascinating. To think, how many people walked and in-and-out of its doors intrigued me. Then, to read how the three women in this novel were also connected to this building, just added more significance to the structure. I had to wonder if there were any standing building today that have these same traits. Hum?
Anyways, back to the book. Following a trio of women, we crisscross over three different time periods (1892, 1920, and 1944) which I found confusing at times as I couldn’t keep everyone straight. These women are all from the same family, just years apart, which made it more confusing to me. I finally wrote everyone’s name down on a piece of paper and drew arrows to keep individuals separated as the romance in this novel adds even more complications.
Somehow over the years, these three women find their way back to New York, to this same building yet they’re there for different reasons. As the novel comes together, you’ll find out what ties them all together.
It’s a mystery that covers many generations. With strong-minded women and a terrific setting this book provided for me an interesting read. 3.5 stars
I read this book for book club otherwise I don’t think I would
have picked it up. From reading the title,
I expected a more somber novel about the gold-rush era, not the adventurous,
dashy story that I read. Baby Doe gave
this era, something to talk about.
I knew nothing about Baby Doe before picking up this
novel. Now, after reading this novel, I want
to read more about her to hear the whole story.
The novel begins with Baby Doe traveling with her new husband
Harvey to Colorado, in the late 1800’s, as Harvey is going to manage a mine
that his father owns. Baby Doe has plans
of her own, to send money back to her parents to help them get by. Her husband ends up not being as business
smart as they thought and Baby Doe ends up helping him out with the business which
I feel is an important part to who she ends up becoming.
The mine becomes the central part of the story with the individuals
who work in it and their families also. Baby Doe becomes a working woman, yet some men
are drawn to her beauty and don’t take her seriously. She’s a smart, determined individual who
knows more than you think.
This was a fast-paced story what once I started, I couldn’t quit. There were numerous times while reading this
story, I found myself talking out loud, reacting to the other characters as
they conversed with Baby Doe. I laughed a
few times and there were even some harsh words spoken, for I thought they were being
very deceitful, given the circumstances. Baby Doe’s story is definitely a story that
you need to read.
Well, I made it! I didn’t
realize upon opening this novel how long it really was, over 600 pages! Did it
feel like 600 pages? Unfortunately for me, it did. The novel started out strong
and ended very strong but the middle dragged for me. That being said, I will read another Karen Rose
novel, I will just stick with a shorter one.
What I really liked about this novel was that Karen wasn’t afraid
to let her audience in on some disturbing scenes. Being a thriller, Karen’s killer is cruel and
hard, and Karen doesn’t gloss these scenes over, she puts the reader right in
on the action. I also enjoyed the
storyline. I was captivated from the beginning
and then the story just rolled along.
Besides the novel dragging some in the middle, there were a
few other issues I had with the novel. The
genre of romantic-suspense is new to me but I had to actually wonder if what
went down between Daisy and Special Agent Gideon could actually happen? Daisy’s a victim and Gideon is an FBI agent
and watching their relationship unfold during the investigation felt questionable,
to me. Do they not realize they are in the middle of an investigation? Do they
not realize what type of investigation it is? I felt that their link also changed
her status and how she was seen by others. Also, what about Daisy’s “service
dog?” I felt sorry for the dog and I think it was actually an emotional support
dog for her.
This is a good, long story with a few slow parts. For me, the second half of the novel, whizzed
by as I began to understand the killer and the motivation behind his
madness. I would like to read more in
this series to see what comes next for these characters.
I want to thank NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing
me a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
I enjoyed listening to this novel. I thought the narration
was excellent and I highly recommend the audio version of this novel. As I listened to the CD’s in my car and
outside in my backyard, I found myself crying, laughing and talking back to the
characters as the story came to life.
I had heard that some individuals aren’t fond of this novel and
how it portrays the characters illness.
In reality, how anyone manages their illness is their own personal
issue. I had a headache w/migraine for 17 years, every-day, which by my
appearance, you never would have known it. However, I know people who have a headache
for a few days and I definitely know they are in pain. It’s all about how you
manage yourself. I also heard about individuals
complaining about the instant love in the novel. I have two things to say, (1)
you need to put yourself in the characters shoes and (2) just stop reading the
book if you’re not feeling it. I do think that if you put yourself in the
characters position in this novel, you will understand why things happened the
way they did.
I shed quite a few tears while listening to this novel. I’m
usually one who gets emotional over a character’s behavior or an incident that
occurs but I found myself moved by what the characters were actually saying. Their words hit deep and I felt what they were
saying, came from within and that got to me.
I liked how the author chose to have the two main characters
have the same illness yet they handled their lives totally different. Their attitudes were almost extreme opposites
from one another. I liked how they each shared a bit of themselves with each
other and they accepted it. They both
know that getting too close to one another could be fatal but they soon realize
that staying apart from one another didn’t feel like the right answer either. It’s a complicated situation that was filled
with humor, compassion, friendship, and strength.